When designing a lightning protection system for a steel-framed building, a common question arises: Should the building's structural steel be used as part of the lightning protection system, or should separate down conductors be installed?
Some building owners and designers are hesitant to use structural steel because they are concerned about directing lightning current through the building. It's a reasonable question, but one that requires an understanding of how lightning behaves.
The important point is that lightning cannot be confined to a single designated path through a building. It will travel along multiple available conductive paths, including the structural steel framework, regardless of whether separate lightning protection conductors are installed.
Understanding this principle is essential to designing an effective lightning protection system.
Why Structural Steel Can Be an Effective Down Conductor
A lightning strike is very different from the electrical current we use in everyday applications. It involves an enormous amount of current delivered in an extremely short period of time.
While copper is a better electrical conductor than steel when comparing material resistance, resistance alone does not determine how lightning current travels. Impedance, which takes into account the rapidly changing nature of lightning current, is also important.
Because of its substantial size and geometry, a building's structural steel framework can provide a very effective, low-impedance path for lightning current.
In fact, when properly incorporated into the lightning protection system, structural steel can serve as an alternative to dedicated cable down conductors.
The Importance of Bonding and Potential Equalization
One of the most important principles of lightning protection is potential equalization.
During a lightning strike, current flows through various conductive paths, causing their electrical potentials to rise and fall rapidly. If nearby conductive components are not properly bonded, significant voltage differences can develop between them.
These differences can lead to sideflashing, where lightning current arcs between conductive components.
Proper bonding helps minimize these potential differences and reduces the risk of sideflashing.
This is why attempting to isolate a building's structural steel from the lightning protection system is generally not a practical solution. Instead, the design should account for the steel framework and provide the necessary electrical connections.
For buildings housing sensitive electronics and other critical systems, potential equalization is particularly important. This principle is reflected in the lightning protection requirements used by organizations such as the Federal Aviation Administration, Department of Energy, and Department of Defense.
What Do Lightning Protection Standards Require?
NFPA 780, Standard for the Installation of Lightning Protection Systems, recognizes the use of structural steel as part of a lightning protection system, provided the applicable requirements are satisfied.
Section 4.18, Structural Metallic Systems, addresses the use of a building's metal framework as a lightning protection conductor.
Among the important design considerations are:
- Electrical continuity: The structural steel must provide a continuous conductive path or be made electrically continuous through appropriate connections.
- Proper bonding: The lightning protection system must be connected to the structural framework using acceptable connection methods.
- Grounding: Appropriate connections between the structural steel and the grounding electrode system must be provided.
- Coordination: The lightning protection design must account for the building's construction and other conductive systems.
These requirements should be considered during the design process, rather than after construction is substantially complete.
Are Separate Down Conductors Still Necessary?
Not necessarily. Where the structural steel meets the applicable requirements, it may be used in place of separate down conductors.
However, every building is different. The continuity of the steel framework, connection details, grounding provisions, and overall lightning protection design must be evaluated.
When structural steel is suitable, using it as part of the system can also offer practical benefits. It may reduce the amount of additional conductor material required and simplify the appearance of the finished installation.
The decision should be based on the building's construction and the requirements of the lightning protection system, rather than an assumption that separate copper conductors are always preferable.
The Bottom Line
A well-designed lightning protection system recognizes that lightning current can travel through multiple paths within a structure.
Rather than attempting to isolate the structural steel, designers should consider how it can be properly incorporated into the lightning protection system to promote potential equalization and reduce the risk of dangerous voltage differences.
With appropriate bonding, grounding, and electrical continuity, structural steel can be an effective component of a building's lightning protection system.
East Coast Lightning Equipment works with lightning protection contractors, engineers, and designers to address technical questions like these. If you have questions about incorporating structural steel into a lightning protection design, contact our team for assistance.
Our Partner:
visit www.sls-us.com to learn about their suite of lightning solutions for special applications
